Reasons of disagreement among Jurists: An Exploratory study
اختلاف فقہاء کے اسباب :ایک تحقیقی مطالعہ
Keywords:
Disagreement, Muslim Jurists, Juristic reviewsAbstract
Difference of opinion among scholars is Rahma(mercy) for Muslims as it help offers verities of solutions to a problem (s) in existence and the differences among them was not in Quran and Hadith but it lies mostly on tiny issues of Shariah..This paper highlights the validity and the degree of disagreement of opinions among four major Muslims Juristic (Maliki ,Hanafi , Shafi’i and Hanbali) with a view to show the reasons and importance of the differences of Juristic opinion for Muslims world over.
References
Al-Jarjani, Allama, Ali bin Muhammad, "Maajim al-Tarifat", Dar al-Fazila, Cairo, Sun.
Al-Amadi, Saif al-Din, Al-Ahkam fi Usul al-Ahkam, Muttaba al-Maarif Besha’ra al-Fajala, Egypt, Volume 4, p. 169
Dehlavi, Shah Wali Allah, Al-Insaf fi bayan subb al-dishab. Urdu translation: Dr. Muhammad Yusuf Goraya, Ulama Academy Department of Awqaf, Lahore, pp. 19-20
Surah Tobah 9: 43
Al-Bukhari, Muhammad bin Ismail, Al-Jami'a al-Sahih, Kitab al-Sayyid, Hadith number: 7288.
Shaz, Allama, Rashid, "Idrak Zawal Ummat", published by Glorious Printers, Daryaganj, New Delhi, IV, 2018, pp. 370-371
Al-Mafula Bala Dehlavi, Shah Wali Allah, Al-Insaf fi Bayan Subb al-Difhal, p. 44
Baghdadi, Abi Bakr Ahmad bin Ali al-Khatib, History of Baghdad. Muktaba Salafiya, Madinah Munawara, Volume 13, p. 325
Al-Mufalah Bala Dehlavi, Shah Wali Allah, Al-Insaf per Bayan Subbas al-Difhal. , p. 30
Ibid.
Faheem Akhtar Nadvi, Jurisprudence Disagreement and the Position of Shah Waliullah (The Case of Saifullah Rahmani), New Delhi: Islamic Book Foundation, 2003, p. 26
Al-Bukhari, Muhammad bin Ismail, Al-Jami’i al-Sahih, Kitab al-Mawaqit al-Salawat, Hadith Number: 581
Al-Qashiri, Muslim bin Hajjaj, “Sahih Muslim”, Kitab al-Salawat, Chapter Al-Masfarin and Qasrha, Hadith No. 833
The above mentioned hadeeth number: 2116
Above, hadith number: 347
Qala Ji, Doctor, Rawas, Jurisprudence of Hazrat Umar (RA), Urdu Translation: Sajid Rahman Siddiqui, Institute of Islamic Education, Mansoora, Lahore, Mada Reza No. 2.
Above
Mufalah Bala Qila Ji, Dr. Rawas, Fiqh Hazrat Umar Radiyallahu Anhu, Zakat No. 4, Part B, Part 3
Al-Mawala Bala Qulaa Ji, Dr. Rawas, Fiqh Musawa Ibn Umar Radiyallahu Anhu, Hali No. 3
Mufaula Bala Qulaa Ji, Dr. Rawas, Jurisprudence of Hazrat Umar, Maad Salat No. 14, Part A
The upper part of Salat No. 9, Part B.
Upper environment. Material removal number 3
The environment above, Article No. 4, Part B
Ahmad bin Hanbal, "Musnad Ahmad", Darl-Hadith Cairo, Sun, Number of Hadith: 7686
Surah Baqarah 2: 228
Surah Nisa 4: 43
Aslahi, Amin Ahsan, "Resolving Jurisprudential Differences in the Islamic State", Faran Foundation, Lahore, p.35
Surah Maidah 5:6
Habib-ur-Rehman, Dr., "Jurisprudential Differences, Reasons and Etiquette", Sharia Academy, Islamic University, Islamabad, 2013, P. 19.21
Siddiqui, Mian Muhammad, "Difference of Jurists, Reasons and Reasons", Fiqr and Nazar, Islamabad, April 30, June 1993, p. 18.
Al-Bukhari,
Ahmad bin Hanbal, "Musnad Ahmad", Number of Hadith: 13867
Al-Sajistani, Abi Dawud, Sulaiman bin Ash’ath, “Sunan Abi Dawud”, Chapter of Al-Ghajid Min al-Ta’un, Number of Hadith: 3103
Nasa'i, Ahmad Bin Shuaib, "Sunan Nasa'i", Chapter Al-Zahab by Al-Zahab, Number of Hadith: 4574
Zaidan, Abdul Kareem, "Alujizfi Usul Fiqh", Urdu translation: Hayat Ulama, Muktaba Rahmaniya, Little Star Printers, Lahore, S.N., p.485
Rahmani, Saifullah, Maulana, The Need for Moderation for Scholars and Leaders, Darul Ash'at, Karachi, 2017, p. 23
Al-Sajistani, Abu Dawud, Sulaiman bin Ash'ath, "Sunan Abi Dawud", Number of Hadith: 411
Bahiqi, Abu Bakr Ahmad bin Hussain, "Sunan al-Kubra, Kitab al-Shahadat, chapter of Qadaa Balimin with al-Shahed, Majlis Dairhal al-Maarif, Hyderabad, 1344 AD, Number of Hadith: 21153
Baghdadi, Abi Bakr Ahmad bin Ali al-Khatib, History of Baghdad. Muktaba Salafiya, Madinah Munawara, Volume 11, p. 525
Al-Tirmidhi, Abu Isa, Muhammad bin Surah, “Al-Jami’ al-Sahih”, Kitab al-Nikah, Chapter Ma Jaya La Nikah Al-Abuli, Hadith Number: 307
Ibn Rushd, "Bida'ita al-Mujtahid", Tabab Bumsir, 1379 AD, Kitab al-Nikah, p. 24
Ibn Abd al-Barr, "Jami Bayan Al-Ilam wa Fazla", Muktaba Muniriyah, Egypt, Volume 3, p. 137
Dehlawi, Shah Waliullah, Uqd al-Jeed fi Haqam al-Jituhad and Taqleed. Urdu Translation: Dr. Mian Muhammad Siddiqui: Sharia Academy International Islamic University Islamabad, p. 111
Dehlavi, Shah Waliullah, Hajjatullah al-Balaga, vol. 2: 1992, Darahiya Uloom, Beirut, Lebanon, vol. 1, p. 457
Kandhalvi, Muhammad Ali Siddiqui, "Imam Azam and the Knowledge of Hadith", Anjaman Darul Uloom Shahabi, Sialkot, p. 32
Hajjatullah Balgha, p. 33
Ibid
Ibid.
Ibid, pp. 111-112
Ibid.
Maulana, Mufti, Muhammad Shafi, Unity of Ummah, Tariq Academy, Asif Printers, Lahore, 2004, p. 28.
Dehlawi, Shah Waliullah, Uqd al-Jeed Fi Haqam al-Juthad and Taqleed. Urdu Translation: Dr. Mian Muhammad Siddiqui: Sharia Academy International Islamic University Islamabad, p. 25
