Ibn Kathir's observations in the criticism of the Sirah’s narrations
نقدِ روایاتِ سیرت میں ابن کثیر ؒکے ملحوظات
Keywords:
Ibn Kath?r, S?rah, methodology, sources, Isr?’?liyy?t, hadith criticism, transmission, innovators (ahl al-bid?ah)Abstract
This study examines Imam Ibn Kathīr’s methodology in Sīrah scholarship, focusing on two key aspects: his sources and references, and his critical evaluation of Sīrah traditions. The research identifies the primary works he directly consulted—such as Ṭabaqāt Ibn Saʿd, Tārīkh al-Umam wa al-Mulūk, and Tārīkh Dimashq—and the secondary sources accessed indirectly. Ibn Kathīr grounded his writings in the Qur’an, authentic ḥadīth, exegetical opinions, and the statements of the salaf, while deliberately avoiding isolated or unreliable reports. His preference was for narrations with strong chains of transmission, comprehensive content, and sound style.In his critical approach, Ibn Kathīr first evaluated reports against the Qur’an and authentic Sunnah, followed by consensus, sound reason, and lived experience. He adopted the principles of reconciliation, abrogation, and preference to resolve apparent contradictions, and highlighted instances of error, textual corruption, or misrepresentation. His stance on Isrā’īliyyāt mirrored that of earlier scholars: acceptance when corroborated by revelation, rejection when contradictory, and conditional citation when neutral.On the conditions of transmission, he required narrators to be Muslim, mature, rational, just, and of upright character, emphasizing detailed criticism over general accreditation. He stressed verbatim transmission, though he allowed bi-l-maʿnā narration for scholars. Regarding innovators (ahl al-bidʿah), Ibn Kathīr upheld the mainstream scholarly position of rejecting the narrations of propagating innovators while cautiously engaging with those of non-propagating ones.Overall, Ibn Kathīr’s methodology reflects a rigorous and balanced approach, marked by a commitment to authenticity, caution against doubtful material, and a systematic framework for assessing Sīrah traditions.
References
Ibn Kathir, Ismail ibn Umar, Al-Bidayah wa al-Nihayah, Dar al-Hijr for Printing and Publishing, Riyadh (1997), Vol. 1, p. 6
Ibid, Vol. 1, p. 7
Ibid, Vol. 1, p. 6
Ibid, Vol. 1, p. 7
Al-Jabari, Ibrahim ibn Umar, The Fees of Modernization in the Sciences of Hadith, Dar Ibn Hazm, Beirut (2000), p. 116
Mowafy, Othman, The Method of Historical Criticism, University Cultural Foundation, Alexandria, (1976), p. 48
Abu Zahu, Muhammad bin Muhammad, Hadith and Hadith, Dar Al-Fikr Al-Arabi, Cairo, (1378), p. 53.
Ibn Al-Jaad, Ali, Musnad Ibn Al-Jaad, Nader Foundation, Beirut, (1990), p. 355.
Method of Historical Criticism, p. 48
Al-Isbahani, Muhammad bin Al-Hassan, The Problem of Hadith and its Explanation, Alam Al-Kutub, Beirut, (1985), p. 74
Dikka: The Beginning and the End, vol. 3, pp. 360, 368, 443, 464, 520. Part 4, pp. 172, 173, 222, 223, 274 .
Ibn Qutaybah, Interpretation of Different Hadiths, Al-Maktab Al-Islami, (1999a), p. 411
Abdullah bin Abdul Rahman Al-Darimi, Al-Sunan, Dar Al-Bashaer, Beirut, (2013), p. 180 to 186
The Beginning and the End, vol. 1, p. 8, vol. 8, p. 578
The Beginning and the End, vol. 3, p. 541: Ibid, vol. 3, pp. 360, 528
Ibid, vol. 8, p. 356
The Beginning and the End, Part 3, pp. 298, 299, 300, 303, 351. Part 4, pp. 13, 19. Part 6, p. 148. Part 7, p. 137.
The Beginning and the End, vol. 3, p. 361. Part 7, p. 666. Part 9, p. 308. Part 11, p. 83
The Beginning and the End, Part 3, pp. 490, 499
The Beginning and the End, vol. 3, p. 431
Imam Ibn Kathir emphasizes referring to his commentary in about 45 places and to the Book of Al-Ahkam in 25 places.
In several places he emphasizes referring to the section on the Stories of the Prophets. Similarly, he suggests looking at other places in Islamic history.
Franz Rosenthal, A history of Muslim historiography, Arabic Translation by: Saleh Ahmed, Ali, Muassisa Al-Risalah, Berut, (1983), P. 31
Muhammad Abd al-Ghani Hasan, Ilm al-Tarikh ind al-Arab, Dar al-Qalam, Beirut, (1962), p. 19
Abd al-Aziz al-Duri, Ilm al-Tarikh ind al-Arab, Baghdad Jamia Press, Baghdad, (1960), p. 17
Ibid, p. 19
Al-Omari, Akram Zia, Seerah al-Nabawiyyah al-Sahihita, Makbatat al-Ubaikan, Riyadh (2009), pp. 53, 56.
Minhaj al-Samaat al-Tarikhi, p. 30
Ibn Sa'd, Muhammad, Tabaqat al-Kubra, Dar al-Kutub al-Alamiyyah, Beirut, (1990), vol.7, p.172
Al-Dhahabi, Muhammad bin Ahmad, Seer Al-Ilaam al-Nabalah, Musisat al-Rasalat, Beirut, (1985), vol. 3, p. 489
Al-Omri, Akram Zia, Marwiat al-Sirat al-Nabawiyyah between the rules of the hadiths and the narrations of the news, Majmaal Malik Fahd for the publication of the Qur’an Al-Sharif, Al-Madinah, p. 10.
See Ibid: Ghalouh, Ahmad, The Prophet’s Biography and the Call to Prayer in the Meccan Era, Al-Risala Foundation, Beirut (2003), p. 197
Al-Haddad, Yasser Khudair, Al-Waqidi and the Methodology of the Writings of Al-Maghazi, Al-Muktab Al-Asriya, Beirut (2009), p. 8, 213
Al-Dhahabi, Muhammad ibn Ahmad, The Biography of the Nobles, Al-Risala Foundation, Beirut (1985), vol. 1, p. 666
Hamada, Farooq, The Sources of the Prophet’s Biography and its Evaluation, Dar Al-Qalam, Damascus, (2010), pp. 145, 154 to 158
Al-Bida’ah and Al-Nihayah, vol. 14, p. 141
Abdul Hamid, Ahmad Mukhtar, The Dictionary of the Modern Arabic Language, ‘Alam Al-Kutb, Beirut (2008), vol. 1, p. 91.
Al-Dhahabi, Muhammad Husayn, The Israelites in Interpretation and Hadith, Maktaba Wahba, Cairo, (1990), p. 13
Ibn Hanbal, Imam Ahmad, Al-Musnad, Mastasaat Al-Risala, Beirut, (2001), H: 14631. Al-Bidayah Wal-Nihayyah, Vol. 3, p. 35
Sahih Bukhari, H: 7362. Al-Bidayah Wal-Nihayyah, Vol. 3, p. 35
Al-Bidayah Wal-Nihayyah, Vol. 3, p. 37
Sahih Bukhari, H: 7363. Al-Bidayah Wal-Nihayyah, Vol. 3, p. 37
Al-Bidayah Wal-Nihayyah, Vol. 1, p. 8. Vol. 3, p. 34
Ibn Taymiyyah, Abu al-Abbas Ahmad, Muqaddam fi Usul al-Tafsir, Maktaba Al-Hayat, Beirut, (1980), 42
Mu'ayyah fi Usul al-Tafsir, p. 42
Sahih Bukhari, H: 3461. Al-Bidayyah wa-Nahiya, Vol. 3, p. 33
Fath al-Bari, Vol. 6, pp. 498, 499
Al-Bidayyah wa-Nahiya, Vol. 1, p. 8. Vol. 3, p. 34
See: Al-Bidaa’ al-Nihaa’, vol. 1, pp. 28, 176, 182, 221, 259. Vol. 3, pp. 36, 84. Vol. 9, pp. 106, 107. Vol. 9, p. 107
Al-Ma’idah:48, Al-Bidaa’ al-Nihaa’, vol. 5, pp. 131, 212, 463. Vol. 6, p. 508
Al-Bidaa’ al-Nihaa’, vol. 3, p. 34
Al-Bidaa’ al-Nihaa’, vol. 1, pp. 7, 8
Ibn al-Salah’s commentary, p. 128
Ibn Kathir, Ismail ibn Umar, Al-Ba’ath al-Hatheeth fi Ikhtasat ‘Ulum al-Hadith, Dar al-Kutb al-Ilmiyah, Beirut, (second edition), pp. 92, 93
Ata ibn Rabah says that “knowledge is hearing.” See: Al-Khatib al-Baghdadi, Ahmad bin Ali bin Thabit, Al-Kifayyah fi ‘Ilm al-Raw’ah, Al-Muktab al-Ilmiyah, Al-Madiyah, (S.N.), p. 314
Al-Haruwa, Ali bin Sultan, Sharh al-Nakhbat al-Fikr, Dar al-Arqam, Beirut, (S.N.), p. 776.
Al-Khatib al-Baghdadi, Ahmad bin Ali bin Thabit, Al-Jami Lakhlaq al-Ravi wa Adaab al-Sami, Maktab al-Maarif, Al-Riyadh, (S.N), Volume 1, pp. 138, 167, 200, 275
Al-Khatib al-Baghdadi, Ahmad bin Ali bin Thabit, Taqiyid al-Ilam, Dar Ihaya al-Sunnah, Beirut, p. 64.
Ibn Abi Hatim, Abd al-Rahman ibn Muhammad, Al-Ala al-Hadith, Al-Hamizi Press, Riyadh, (2006), vol.5, p. 182
Al-Jami Lakhlaq al-Rawi, Vol. 1, p. 275
Ibn al-Salah, Uthman ibn Abd al-Rahman, al-Muqadamat Ibn al-Salah, Dar al-Fikr al-Mudhamdin, Beirut, (1986), pp. 119, 141, 239
Ibn Hajar, Ahmad bin Ali, Nakhbat al-Fikr fi muttaf al-Ahl al-Athar, Dar al-Hadith, Cairo, (1997), vol. 4, p. 726
Ibn al-Salah, al-Maqada, pp. 123, 191, 389. Ibn Katheer, Al-Ba'ath al-Hathith, pp. 92 to 94. Al-Jami Lakhlaq al-Ravi, Vol. 2, p. 201. Al-Maqdisi, Muhammad bin Tahir, Zakhirah al-Nawab, Dar al-Salif, Riyadh, (1996), vol. 6, p. 1156
Al-Baa'ith al-Hathith, p. 94
Ibn Abi Hatim, Al-Jarh and al-Mudham, Dar Ahyaya al-Turath al-Arabi, Beirut, (1952), vol. 2, p. 27.
Al-Jarh and Tadeel, Vol. 1, p. 10
See: Ibn al-Mulqan, Umar bin Ali bin Ahmad, al-Badr al-Munir, Dar al-Hijrah, Riyadh (2004), vol. 3, p. 39.
Al-Jarjani, Ali ibn Muhammad, Al-Dibaj al-Mahhab in the term of al-Hadith, Mustafa al-Babi al-Halabi Publishing House, Egypt, (1931), p. 49
Ibid, p. 51
Ibn Hajar, Nakhbat al-Fikr, p. 726.
Al-Saleh, Subhi Ibrahim, Hadith Sciences and Terminology, Dar Al-Ilm for Millions, Beirut, (1984), p. 331
Al-Suyuti, Abd al-Rahman bin Abi Bakr, Training the Narrator, Dar Tayyaba, Riyadh, pp. 62, 63
Al-Dibaj Al-Madhahib, p. 51
Ibn Hanbal, Imam Ahmad, Al-Illal and the Knowledge of Men, Dar Al-Khani, Riyadh, (2001), vol. 1, p. 34
Muslim bin Al-Hajjaj, Imam, Al-Tasa'b, Maktaba'at Al-Tanwir, Saudi Arabia, (1410 AH), p. 188
Ibn al-Salah's case, p. 128
Al-Kifayyah in the Science of Narration, pp. 52, 23
See:, Hadith Sciences and Terminology, p. 331
Ibn Hajar, Ahmad bin Ali, Nuzhat al-Nazar fi Tawfiz Nukhbat al-Fikr, Safir Press, Riyadh, (1422 AH), p. 120
The reasons include the narrator's delusion, doubt (ashbah), negation of clear hearing, weakening of the narrator, uniqueness, interruption, the suspended becoming a marfoo (marf?d), change of news, heart (reversal in the chain of transmission), linking of transmitted traditions, the gathering of multiple narrators in one hadith, the imposition of some hadiths on others, identification of ambiguous narrators, distinguishing between unreliable narrators, correcting the names of narrators, clarification of errors, etc.
Ibn Abd Al-Barr, Yusuf Ibn Abd Allah, Jami Bayan Al-Ilam Wa Fazlah, Dar Ibn Al-Jawzi, Al-Saudia, (1994), vol.1, p. 345
Al-Asbahani, Muhammad ibn al-Hasan, Mishal al-Hadith and Bayanah, Alam al-Kutub, Beirut, (1985), p. 74
Al-Jami Lakhlaq al-Rawi, vol. 1, pp. 270, 285
Nakhbat al-Fikr, pp. 3, 7
Al-Jami Lakhlaq al-Rawi, vol. 2, p. 111
Al-Sakhawi, Muhammad bin Abd al-Rahman, Fath al-Mughith in Sharh al-Fiyat al-Hadith for Iraq, Maktablat al-Sunnah, Egypt, (2003), vol.3, p. 265
Al-Hamdani, Muhammad bin Musa, Al-Laghaaf fi Nasakh wal Mansukh Min Al-Aqtior, Department of Al-Maarif al-Othmaniya, Hyderabad, (1359 AH), p.43
Al-Hadith, Vol. 1, p. 22
Al-Zarqi, Adil Abd al-Shakkur, Qa'a'il al-Allah and Qur'ain Al-Tarjih, Dar al-Muhaddath for publication and distribution, Al-Riyadh, (1425 AH), p. 25
Al-Badayah Willanhaya, Vol. 4, p. 134. J5, pp. 76, 79, 80
Ibid, Vol. 3, p. 464. J4, p. 79
Ibid, Vol. 4, pp. 80, 190, 447. J5, p. 21. J6, p. 49, 615. J7, p. 115
Ibid, Vol.3, pp. 440, 441, 455, 456, 516
Ibid, Vol. 3, p. 528
Ibid, Vol. 4, p. 13, 198. J7, p. 662. Vol.8, pp. 23, 289, 298, 443
Ibid, Volume 3, pp. 456, 572. Volume 4, pp. 174, 206.
Ibid, Vol. 3, p. 564. J4, pp. 14, 16, 17, 68, 114. J5, p. 31. J6, p. 120. J7, pp. 74, 75
Ibid, Vol. 5, p. 180. J8, p. 323
Ibid, Vol. 3, pp. 447, 587. Vol. 4, pp. 24, 55, 88, 91
Al-Badaiya Wal-Nahiya, Vol. 4, p. 248. J5, p. 31, 104. Vol. 6, p. 425
Al-Ba'ath al-Hathith in the Summary of Hadith Sciences, p. 175
Al-Shalash, Adnan Muhammad, Ibn Kathir and His Influence in Hadith Science, Narration and Knowledge, Dar al-Nafais, Amman, (2005), p. 546
Tadrib al-Rawi, p. 652
Al-Ba'ath al-Hathith, p. 175
Qarni, Mahmoud, Ibn Kathir's Method of Authenticating Sunnah Texts, Cairo University, (2003), p. 70
Al-Bida'ah and Al-Nahiyah, Vol. 1, p. 7
Fath al-Mughaith, Vol. 4, p. 70
The traditions related to Shaq al-Sadr are an example of this. See: Al-Bidaa’ al-Nihaa’, vol. 3, p. 333
Al-Ba’ath al-Hathith, p. 175
Al-Bidaa’ al-Nihaa’, vol. 6, p. 53
Ibn Kathir’s Method of Authenticating the Texts of the Sunnah, p. 169
Ibn Kathir and His Influence in the Science of Hadith, Narration and Widara’, pp. 389, 546
Al-Bidaa’ al-Nihaa’, vol. 3, p. 409. Vol. 4, pp. 166, 183, 185, 394, 412 etc.
Kafi, Abu Bakr, Minhaj al-Imam al-Bukhari fi ta’zih ahadith wa ta’lilah, Dar Ibn Hazm, Beirut, (2000), p. 102
Introduction by Ibn al-Salah, p. 114
Al-Jami’ la-Akhlaq al-Rawi, vol. 1, p. 136
Ibn al-Mubarak, Abdullah ibn Ja’far, al-Zuhd wa’l-Aqlaq, Dar al-Kutb al-Ilmiyah, Beirut, p. 20
Al-Jami’ la-Akhlaq al-Rawi, vol. 1, p. 137
Ibn Rajab, Abd al-Rahman ibn Ahmad, Sharh ‘Illal al-Tirmidhi, Maktaba’t al-Manar, Jordan, (1987), p. 356
Ibid, vol. 1, p. 157
Al-Jami’ la-Akhlaq al-Rawi, vol. 1, p. 138
Ibid, vol. 1, p. 138
Sharh ‘Illal al-Tirmidhi, vol. 1, p. 357
Ibid, vol. 1, p. 356
Ibid, vol. 1, p. 357
Al-Khatib al-Baghdadi, Al-Kifayah, p. 120
Mu'awiyah Ibn al-Salah, p. 114
Al-Ba'ath al-Hathith, p. 100
Ibid, pp. 100, 101
Sharh Illal al-Tirmidhi, p. 356
Ibid, p. 356
Al-Kakfayyah fi ‘Ilm al-Rawiyah, p. 125
Mu’awiyah Ibn al-Salah, p. 114
Sharh Illal al-Tirmidhi, p. 356
Al-Ba’ath al-Hatheeth, p. 99
Sharh Illal al-Tirmidhi, p. 357, 358
Al-Ba’ath al-Hatheeth, p. 99
Ibid, p. 101
Ibid, p. 101
Al-Bida’ah wal-Niha’ah, vol. 4, pp. 101, 538. vol. 6, pp. 624. vol. 8, pp. 100, 197 to 200. vol. 10, p. 414
Ibid, vol. 5, pp. 94, 267, 307
Ibid, vol. 3, pp. 374, 427. Vol. 4, pp. 66, 67, 101, 313, 538. J5, p. 672. Vol.8, pp. 36, 99, 100, 190, 195, 197 to 200, 372
Ibid, Vol. 4, pp. 66, 67, 308 to 310, 313. J5, p. 672. Volume 8, pp. 94, 195, 197 to 200. J6, pp. 35, 36
Ibid, Vol. 4, p. 322
